These associations record declared relationships between independently preserved public records and documents. An association does not by itself establish evidential sufficiency, factual verification, legal status, authorship, or proof of the linked record.
Encrypted email read receipt
View association · View linked document
Confirms that Darren Smith of the Medical Council of Ireland viewed the encrypted message sent on 27 November 2020, preserving evidence of recipient access within the complaint communication chronology.
| Reference identifier | — |
| Category | Read Receipt |
| Document format | PNG |
| Publication date | 2026-07-23 |
PPC opinion on complaint C397/19
View association · View linked document
Official Medical Council correspondence recording the Preliminary Proceedings Committee’s opinion that there was not sufficient cause to warrant further action in relation to complaint C397/19. The document preserves this procedural stage within the complaint chronology and should be read separately from the Medical Council’s subsequent decision.
| Reference identifier | C397/19 |
| Category | Official Correspondence |
| Document format | PDF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-23 |
Secure File Transfer Notification
View association · View linked document
Secure File Transfer notification accompanying Medical Council correspondence dated 25 November 2020. Documents the encrypted delivery mechanism used for correspondence relating to complaint reference C397/19.
| Reference identifier | Medical Council – Secure File Transfer Notification (25 November 2020) |
| Category | Correspondence (Email) |
| Document format | PDF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-23 |
Supporting document
View association · View linked document
Documents the secure electronic transmission of Medical Council correspondence on 25 November 2020. Preserved independently from the attached letter to maintain communication provenance and administrative chronology.
| Reference identifier | — |
| Category | Administrative Correspondence |
| Document format | PNG |
| Publication date | 2026-07-23 |
Encrypted email read receipt
View association · View linked document
Documents that the encrypted Medical Council correspondence was viewed by the intended recipient, preserving communication provenance within the complaint chronology.
| Reference identifier | — |
| Category | Administrative Correspondence |
| Document format | PNG |
| Publication date | 2026-07-23 |
Statutory legislative reference
View association · View linked document
Preserves Section 59 of the Medical Practitioners Act 2007 as the statutory framework governing the Preliminary Proceedings Committee’s handling of complaints. This legislative reference provides legal context for the associated procedural correspondence without constituting case-specific evidence.
| Reference identifier | — |
| Category | Legislation |
| Document format | PDF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-23 |
Acknowledgement of Medical Council correspondence
View association · View linked document
Reply acknowledging receipt of the Medical Council’s secure communication relating to complaint reference C397/19. Preserves the continuity of correspondence within the complaint chronology without extending the evidential scope of the accompanying documents.
| Reference identifier | — |
| Category | Email Correspondence |
| Document format | PDF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-23 |
Medical Council investigation notice
View association · View linked document
Official Medical Council correspondence documenting that the Preliminary Proceedings Committee directed a notice under Section 59(7) of the Medical Practitioners Act 2007 in relation to complaint reference C397/19. This document records a formal procedural step within the complaint process and preserves the associated statutory context.
| Reference identifier | — |
| Category | Official Correspondence |
| Document format | PDF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-23 |
Secure transmission of Medical Council correspondence
View association · View linked document
Documents the secure electronic transmission of Medical Council correspondence relating to complaint reference C397/19. Establishes the provenance, sender, recipient, transmission date, and existence of the accompanying official correspondence, independent of the contents of the attached letter.
| Reference identifier | — |
| Category | Secure Email Notification |
| Document format | PNG |
| Publication date | 2026-07-23 |
Supporting Correspondence
View association · View linked document
Supporting correspondence associated with the Medical Council complaint chronology. This communication notifies the assigned case worker of a counselling appointment arranged during the complaint process and preserves its contextual relationship to the public record without extending the evidential scope of either object.
| Reference identifier | — |
| Category | Email Correspondence |
| Document format | PNG |
| Publication date | 2026-07-23 |
Supporting Clinical Evidence
View association · View linked document
Supporting financial and administrative evidence associated with the Medical Council complaint chronology. This receipt independently confirms attendance at a Doctor 365 consultation on 14 April 2020 and preserves its contextual relationship to the public record without extending the evidential scope of either object.
| Reference identifier | — |
| Category | Receipt |
| Document format | PDF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-23 |
Supporting Clinical Evidence
View association · View linked document
Supporting pharmacy dispensing evidence associated with the Medical Council complaint chronology. This document independently records the dispensing of the prescribed medication on 14 April 2020 and preserves its contextual relationship to the public record without extending the evidential scope of either object.
| Reference identifier | 004/683 |
| Category | Prescription Claim Form |
| Document format | PDF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-23 |
Supporting Clinical Evidence
View association · View linked document
Supporting financial and administrative evidence associated with the Medical Council complaint chronology. This receipt independently confirms attendance at a Doctor 365 consultation on 14 April 2020 and preserves its contextual relationship to the public record without extending the evidential scope of either object.
| Reference identifier | — |
| Category | Prescription |
| Document format | PDF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-23 |
Supporting Clinical Evidence
View association · View linked document
Supporting clinical prescription associated with the Medical Council complaint chronology. This published copy preserves the contemporaneous prescription and its transmission as supporting material within the complaint process without extending the evidential scope of either object.
| Reference identifier | Doctor 365, Darren Smith, Medical Council of Ireland, prescription, Fucidin H, fusidic acid, hydrocortisone, topical cream, Nicholas Moloney, 14 April 2020 |
| Category | Prescription |
| Document format | PNG |
| Publication date | 2026-07-23 |
Supporting Clinical Evidence
View association · View linked document
Supporting financial and administrative evidence linked to the Medical Council complaint chronology. This receipt independently confirms payment for an injection service on 2 April 2020 and preserves its contextual relationship to the public record without extending the evidential scope of either object.
| Reference identifier | — |
| Category | Receipt |
| Document format | PDF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-23 |
Supporting Clinical Evidence
View association · View linked document
Supporting clinical evidence linked to the Medical Council complaint chronology. This document preserves contextual provenance and should be interpreted within its own evidential boundaries.
| Reference identifier | — |
| Category | Clinical Correspondence |
| Document format | PDF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-23 |
Supporting email correspondence
View association · View linked document
Automatic reply issued by the Medical Council of Ireland acknowledging receipt of the submitted correspondence.
| Reference identifier | — |
| Category | Correspondence (Email) |
| Document format | PNG |
| Publication date | 2026-07-21 |
Evidence Inventory
View association · View linked document
* Printed administrative information (the receipt itself), and
* Handwritten annotations added afterwards.
| Reference identifier | 23805 |
| Category | Financial Record |
| Document format | PDF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-21 |
Evidence Inventory
View association · View linked document
Facet Joint Injection - Patient Information Leaflet
| Reference identifier | — |
| Category | Patient Information Leaflet (or Medical Information if that better matches your taxonomy) |
| Document format | PDF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-21 |
Evidence Inventory
View association · View linked document
Associated as evidence inventory during record assembly.
| Reference identifier | — |
| Category | Clinical Note (or Medical Correspondence if that’s one of your categories) |
| Document format | PDF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-21 |
Supporting email correspondence
View association · View linked document
Email correspondence associated with this record.
| Reference identifier | — |
| Category | Correspondence (Email) |
| Document format | PNG |
| Publication date | 2026-07-21 |
Read receipt notification
View association · View linked document
Automated notification confirming that the encrypted correspondence relating to complaint C397/19 was viewed through the Medical Council’s secure messaging service.
| Reference identifier | NM-MC-SHAREFILE-READ-RECEIPT-20200204-001 |
| Category | Correspondence (Read Receipt Notification) |
| Document format | PNG |
| Publication date | 2026-07-20 |
Supporting correspondence
View association · View linked document
Confirmation from the complainant that the email dated 27 January 2020 should be considered as part of complaint C397/19, acknowledging that it could be provided to Pro Dominic Harmon for his information.
| Reference identifier | NM-CORR-EMAIL-20200204-001 |
| Category | Correspondence (Email) |
| Document format | RTF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-20 |
Request for confirmation regarding complaint evidence
View association · View linked document
Official Medical Council correspondence requesting confirmation that the email dated 27 January 2020 should be considered as part of complaint C397/19 and advising that, if confirmed, it would be provided to Dr Dominic Harmon for his information.
| Reference identifier | NM-MC-LETTER-20200204-001 |
| Category | Correspondence — Official Letter |
| Document format | PDF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-20 |
Encrypted notification of Medical Council correspondence
View association · View linked document
Secure email notification advising that confidential correspondence relating to complaint C397/19 was available for collection.
| Reference identifier | NM-MC-ENCRYPTED-NOTIFICATION-20200204-001 |
| Category | Correspondence (Encrypted Email Notification) |
| Document format | PNG |
| Publication date | 2026-07-20 |
Preliminary Proceedings Committee Investigation Directions — 30 January 2020
View association · View linked document
Letter issued by the Medical Council advising that the Preliminary Proceedings Committee assigned complaint C397/19 to a Case Officer and directed the initial statutory investigation.
| Reference identifier | NM-MC-LETTER-20200130-001 |
| Category | Correspondence – Official Letter |
| Document format | PDF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-19 |
Supporting correspondence
View association · View linked document
Original contemporaneous covering correspondence accompanying documentation issued by the Medical Council concerning complaint reference C397/19. Published independently and associated as supporting correspondence. This association does not itself establish evidential conclusions beyond the governed relationship.
| Reference identifier | NM-CORR-EMAIL-20200130-002 |
| Category | Correspondence (Email) |
| Document format | PNG |
| Publication date | 2026-07-19 |
Supporting correspondence
View association · View linked document
Original contemporaneous encrypted email notification advising of a confidential Medical Council communication relating to complaint reference C397/19. Published independently and associated as supporting correspondence. This association does not itself establish evidential conclusions beyond the governed relationship.
| Reference identifier | NM-CORR-EMAIL-20200130-001 |
| Category | Correspondence (Email) |
| Document format | PNG |
| Publication date | 2026-07-19 |
Supporting correspondence
View association · View linked document
Original contemporaneous automated ShareFile password reset email generated during attempts to access encrypted Medical Council correspondence. Published independently and associated as supporting correspondence. This association does not itself establish evidential conclusions beyond the governed relationship.
| Reference identifier | NM-CORR-EMAIL-20191219-001 |
| Category | Correspondence (Email) |
| Document format | PNG |
| Publication date | 2026-07-19 |
Supporting correspondence
View association · View linked document
Original contemporaneous automatic acknowledgement confirming receipt of correspondence concerning Medical Council ShareFile login issues and advising of the Case Officer's absence. Published independently and associated as supporting correspondence. This association does not itself establish evidential conclusions beyond the governed relationship.
| Reference identifier | NM-CORR-EMAIL-20191218-005 |
| Category | Correspondence (Email) |
| Document format | PNG |
| Publication date | 2026-07-19 |
Supporting correspondence
View association · View linked document
Original contemporaneous correspondence reporting an authentication error encountered while attempting to access Medical Council complaint documents through the secure ShareFile platform. Published independently and associated as supporting correspondence. This association does not itself establish evidential conclusions beyond the governed relationship.
| Reference identifier | NM-CORR-EMAIL-20191218-004 |
| Category | Correspondence (Email) |
| Document format | PNG |
| Publication date | 2026-07-19 |
Supporting correspondence
View association · View linked document
Original automated ShareFile system email providing password reset instructions required to access complaint-related documents delivered through the Medical Council's secure document-sharing platform. Published independently and associated as supporting correspondence. This association does not itself establish evidential conclusions beyond the governed relationship.
| Reference identifier | NM-CORR-SYSTEM-EMAIL-20191218-001 |
| Category | Correspondence (System Email) |
| Document format | PNG |
| Publication date | 2026-07-19 |
Supporting correspondence
View association · View linked document
Original contemporaneous Medical Council email notifying the complainant that an encrypted message relating to case C397/19 was available through the Medical Council's secure email service. Published independently and associated as supporting correspondence. This association does not itself establish evidential conclusions beyond the governed relationship.
| Reference identifier | NM-CORR-EMAIL-20191218-003 |
| Category | Correspondence (Email) |
| Document format | PNG |
| Publication date | 2026-07-19 |
Supporting correspondence
View association · View linked document
Original contemporaneous Medical Council email providing secure ShareFile access for complaint-related documents. Published independently and associated as supporting correspondence. This association does not itself establish evidential conclusions beyond the governed relationship.
| Reference identifier | NM-CORR-EMAIL-20191218-002 |
| Category | Correspondence (Email) |
| Document format | PNG |
| Publication date | 2026-07-19 |
Supporting procedural publication
View association · View linked document
Official Medical Council publication describing the procedures followed by the Preliminary Proceedings Committee when considering complaints. Published independently and associated as supporting procedural documentation. This association does not itself establish evidential conclusions beyond the governed relationship.
| Reference identifier | NM-MC-PROCEDURES-20160601-001 |
| Category | Procedural Publication |
| Document format | PDF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-19 |
Supporting guidance publication
View association · View linked document
Official Medical Council information sheet identifying patient advocacy organisations and support services available to complainants. Published independently and associated as supporting procedural documentation. This association does not itself establish evidential conclusions beyond the governed relationship.
| Reference identifier | NM-MC-GUIDE-20191205-002 |
| Category | Guidance Publication |
| Document format | PDF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-19 |
Supporting guidance publication
View association · View linked document
Official Medical Council guidance publication provided with correspondence concerning the complaint process. Published independently and associated as supporting procedural documentation. This association does not itself establish evidential conclusions beyond the governed relationship.
| Reference identifier | NM-MC-GUIDE-20191218-001 |
| Category | Guidance Publication |
| Document format | PDF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-19 |
Supporting correspondence
View association · View linked document
Original contemporaneous correspondence issued by the Medical Council of Ireland acknowledging the complaint, confirming its referral to the respondent doctor and explaining the Preliminary Proceedings Committee process. Published independently and associated as supporting correspondence. This association does not itself establish evidential conclusions beyond the governed relationship.
| Reference identifier | NM-CORR-LETTER-20191218-001 |
| Category | Correspondence (Letter) |
| Document format | PDF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-19 |
Supporting correspondence
View association · View linked document
Original contemporaneous email correspondence issued by the Medical Council of Ireland on 5 December 2019 transmitting documentation relating to the formal complaint. Published independently and associated as supporting correspondence. This association does not itself establish evidential conclusions beyond the governed relationship.
| Reference identifier | Medical Council of Ireland, Shirley Murphy, Regulation Officer, Professional Standards, Complaint, Medical Council Complaint, Clinical Complaint, Correspondence |
| Category | Correspondence (Email) |
| Document format | PNG |
| Publication date | 2026-07-19 |
Digital provenance record
View association · View linked document
Association created following publication. Relationship recorded between the governed digital photograph and its independently governed provenance record in accordance with the CDE governance model.
| Reference identifier | NM-DIGITAL-PROVENANCE-20190802-001 |
| Category | Digital Provenance Record |
| Document format | PNG |
| Publication date | 2026-07-19 |
Supporting correspondence
View association · View linked document
Original contemporaneous email correspondence requesting a specialist referral to Dr Dominic A. Hegarty. Published independently and associated as supporting correspondence. This association does not itself establish evidential conclusions beyond the governed relationship.
| Reference identifier | NM-CORR-EMAIL-20191126-001 |
| Category | Correspondence (Email) |
| Document format | PDF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-19 |
Supporting clinical note
View association · View linked document
Original contemporaneous handwritten clinical note created during a Pain Medicine consultation on 7 November 2019. Published independently and associated as supporting clinical documentation. This association does not itself establish evidential conclusions beyond the governed relationship.
| Reference identifier | NM-CLINICAL-NOTE-20191107-002 |
| Category | Clinical Note |
| Document format | JPEG |
| Publication date | 2026-07-19 |
Supporting clinical note
View association · View linked document
Original contemporaneous handwritten clinical note created during a Pain Medicine consultation on 7 November 2019. Published independently and associated as supporting clinical documentation. This association does not itself establish evidential conclusions beyond the governed relationship.
| Reference identifier | NM-CLINICAL-NOTE-20191107-001 |
| Category | Clinical Note |
| Document format | JPEG |
| Publication date | 2026-07-19 |
Supporting prescription record
View association · View linked document
Original contemporaneous prescription reorder form recording the patient's repeat medication schedule as at 2 June 2017. Published independently and associated as supporting clinical documentation. This association does not itself establish evidential conclusions beyond the governed relationship.
| Reference identifier | NM-PRESCRIPTION-REORDER-20170602-001 |
| Category | Prescription Reorder Form |
| Document format | JPEG |
| Publication date | 2026-07-19 |
Supporting prescription
View association · View linked document
Original contemporaneous hospital prescription issued during attendance at UL Hospitals – Croom Hospital on 7 November 2019. Published independently and associated as supporting clinical correspondence. This association does not itself establish evidential conclusions beyond the governed relationship.
| Reference identifier | NM-PRESCRIPTION-20191107-001 |
| Category | Prescription |
| Document format | JPEG |
| Publication date | 2026-07-19 |
Supporting membership and usage record
View association · View linked document
Original Microsoft Excel workbook containing contemporaneous membership and individual usage information relating to Nick Moloney at Woodstock during 2019. Published independently in its native spreadsheet format and associated as a supporting record. This association does not itself establish evidential conclusions beyond the governed relationship.
| Reference identifier | NM-SPREADSHEET-WOODSTOCK-USAGE-2019-001 |
| Category | Membership and Usage Records |
| Document format | XLS |
| Publication date | 2026-07-18 |
Supporting correspondence
View association · View linked document
Original contemporaneous email correspondence confirming a Pain Medicine review appointment for 3 December 2018. Published independently and associated as supporting correspondence. This association does not itself establish evidential conclusions beyond the governed relationship.
| Reference identifier | NM-CORR-EMAIL-20181114-001 |
| Category | Correspondence (Email) |
| Document format | PDF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-18 |
Supporting correspondence
View association · View linked document
Original contemporaneous email correspondence requesting a repeat prescription for ongoing medications. Published independently and associated as supporting correspondence. This association does not itself establish evidential conclusions beyond the governed relationship.
| Reference identifier | NM-CORR-EMAIL-20190709-002 |
| Category | Correspondence (Email) |
| Document format | PDF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-18 |
Supporting correspondence
View association · View linked document
Original contemporaneous email correspondence requesting removal of Zimoclone (Zopiclone) from a repeat prescription following advice received from Shannon Doc. Published independently and associated as supporting correspondence. This association does not itself establish evidential conclusions beyond the governed relationship.
| Reference identifier | NM-CORR-EMAIL-20190709-001 |
| Category | Correspondence (Email) |
| Document format | PDF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-18 |
Supporting correspondence
View association · View linked document
Original contemporaneous email correspondence concerning amendment of a repeat prescription to replace Amitriptyline with Stilnoct in accordance with a hospital prescription. Published independently and associated as supporting correspondence. This association does not itself establish evidential conclusions beyond the governed relationship.
| Reference identifier | NM-CORR-EMAIL-20190507-001 |
| Category | Correspondence (Email) |
| Document format | PDF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-18 |
Supporting correspondence
View association · View linked document
Original contemporaneous email correspondence concerning treatment received at Shannon Doc for back problems and the possible need for further injections. Published independently and associated as supporting correspondence. This association does not itself establish evidential conclusions beyond the governed relationship.
| Reference identifier | NM-CORR-EMAIL-20180522-001 |
| Category | Correspondence (Email) |
| Document format | PDF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-18 |
Supporting correspondence
View association · View linked document
Original contemporaneous email correspondence concerning commencement of Neurontin (Gabapentin), prescription updates and discussion of a rehabilitation option using an anti-gravity treadmill. Published independently and associated as supporting correspondence. This association does not itself establish evidential conclusions beyond the governed relationship.
| Reference identifier | NM-CORR-EMAIL-20180416-001 |
| Category | Correspondence (Email) |
| Document format | PDF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-18 |
Supporting correspondence
View association · View linked document
Original contemporaneous email correspondence concerning the scheduling of a Pain Medicine review appointment relating to Botox injections. Published independently and associated as supporting correspondence. This association does not itself establish evidential conclusions beyond the governed relationship.
| Reference identifier | NM-CORR-EMAIL-20190419-001 |
| Category | Correspondence (Email) |
| Document format | PDF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-18 |
Supporting correspondence
View association · View linked document
Original contemporaneous email correspondence relating to a Pain Medicine review appointment. The preserved correspondence includes the original conversational context as sent. Published independently and associated as supporting correspondence. This association does not itself establish evidential conclusions beyond the governed relationship.
| Reference identifier | NM-CORR-EMAIL-20180911-001 |
| Category | Correspondence (Email) |
| Document format | PDF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-18 |
Supporting correspondence
View association · View linked document
Original contemporaneous email correspondence confirming an earlier Pain Medicine appointment on 30 September 2019. Published independently and associated as supporting correspondence. This association does not itself establish evidential conclusions beyond the governed relationship.
| Reference identifier | NM-CORR-EMAIL-20190930-001 |
| Category | Correspondence (Email) |
| Document format | PDF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-18 |
Supporting correspondence
View association · View linked document
Original contemporaneous email correspondence concerning a request for an earlier Pain Medicine appointment following changes in medication. Published independently and associated as supporting correspondence. This association does not itself establish evidential conclusions beyond the governed relationship.
| Reference identifier | NM-CORR-EMAIL-20190712-001 |
| Category | Correspondence (Email) |
| Document format | PDF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-18 |
Supporting document
View association · View linked document
Original contemporaneous receipt documenting a financial transaction for a medical consultation. Published independently and associated as supporting documentation. This association does not itself assert evidential conclusions beyond the governed relationship.
| Reference identifier | NM-RECEIPT-HR-20180530-001 |
| Category | Receipt |
| Document format | JPEG |
| Publication date | 2026-07-17 |
Supporting clinical note
View association · View linked document
Published handwritten clinical note preserved as a contemporaneous document relevant to the Complaint record.
| Reference identifier | NM-CLIN-NOTE-001 |
| Category | Clinical Note |
| Document format | JPEG |
| Publication date | 2026-07-17 |
Supporting audio recording
View association · View linked document
Published audio recording preserved as a contemporaneous artefact relevant to the Complaint record.
| Reference identifier | NM-AUDIO-20190719-001 |
| Category | Audio Recording |
| Document format | M4A |
| Publication date | 2026-07-17 |
Supporting correspondence
View association · View linked document
Published email preserved as contemporaneous correspondence relevant to the Complaint record.
| Reference identifier | NM-CORR-EMAIL-20190729-001 |
| Category | Correspondence |
| Document format | PDF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-17 |
Supporting correspondence
View association · View linked document
Published email preserved as contemporaneous correspondence relevant to the Complaint record.
| Reference identifier | NM-CORR-EMAIL-20190507-001 |
| Category | Correspondence |
| Document format | PDF |
| Publication date | 2026-07-17 |
Initial Complaint Evidence Package — Medical Council of Ireland
View association · View linked document
Initial evidence package submitted with the formal Medical Council of Ireland complaint on 2 December 2019. This ZIP archive contains the original collection of supporting documents, emails, referral letters, clinical records, prescription records, screenshots, and other evidential material accompanying the initial complaint submission.
| Reference identifier | NM-EVID-PKG-20191202-001 |
| Category | Evidence Package |
| Document format | PNG |
| Publication date | 2026-07-16 |